Giant Saddle Bag Shootout!

If you have done any bike packing, chances are you have a seat bag. Josh goes over the various brands and sizes we carry in this comprehensive large seat bag shootout!

[Video Transcription]

Hey, I am Josh with Bike Shop Hub. Today I am doing a giant bike saddle bag shootout. I will be showing off all the the giant saddle bags we carry at Bike Shop Hub and give you an overview and how the compare to one another.

I am going to start with the Revelate bags this is the Viscacha which is Revelates larger pack, its pretty big. The volume is up to 14 liters. Next we have the Pika, which is paked quite a bit smaller, but it will accommodate up to 12 liters. The bottom is quite a bit deeper on the Viscacha as compared to the Pika. Moving on we get to Revelates other take on the saddle bag, the Terrapin it takes up to a 14 liter dry bag.

Apidura has a saddle bag that is quite similar to the design of the Revelate bags. They have 3 sizes, their large bag is 17.5 liters and it is the largest of all the saddle bags. That is the Apidura large saddle bag compare it to the medium at 14 liters and finally the small at 11 liters.

Moving on to a bag similar to the Terrapin, the Restrap Carry Everything which is another holster style bag and it works in a similar way and carries a similar volume.

Then the Blackburn Outpost Seat Pack is yet another holster style bag that is 10.5 liters so it is the smallest of the group.

We are going to move on over and show you how these fit onto a bicycle.

Starting back with our lineup, with the Viscacha and it fits in there nicely. The Pika, a bit smaller with more tire clearance. The Terrapin, see how that fits in there, not quite as much tire clearance as the other two.

Now the Apidura bags, these have two straps on the seat post, the large size does. The medium also with two straps and finally the small with a single strap and plenty of tire clearance.

The Restrap carry everything, not as much tire clearance on this bag.

The Blackburn outpack, another two strap design with quite a bit of tire clearance.

Alright for the final part of my comparison today, I am going to really put my head into this and figure out how well my head fits into these bags. We really like to head into things around here. So I have a special hair dew today, to show off while I need a hat. My head size is 23 inches.

We will start out with the Pika, no, it does not really fit, a bit small. How about the Viscacha? Ah, nice fit. Very good hat, great for a party. Alright, lets see how the Terrapin works, I is always interesting to figure out what the right angle is to wear these as a hat. There we go! Fits on pretty well.

Alright, Apidura large. This hat must work great. I am going to give myself a little brim. Yeah! Alright, Apidura medium. Ah yeah, nice and snug. Good fit! Apidura small, wow, that is actually a perfect fit.

This one is interesting. Not sure, maybe Darth Vader? Alright, Oh, great fit. Perfect hat actually! Yes, very good.

Lets see if the Blackburn thing works. Charge!!!

Thanks Everyone, I’m Josh with Bike Shop Hub.

Sign up for our Adventure-Packed Newsletter

Get our latest touring, commuting and family cycling posts and sales delivered to your inbox!
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

4 thoughts on “Giant Saddle Bag Shootout!”

  1. tom ligman says:

    Would any of them hold a 12″x8″x0.5″ laptop? It would be awfully nice if I could buy one bag for bikepacking and have it also useful for the few times a year I need to carry a laptop to work with me.

  2. I liked your bag review. My question is which bag is the most narrow from the seatpost. I use Carradice seatbags because the frame sets the bag apart so as the back of my leg does not rub against the bag. I am looking to go a bit more aero using the new saddle bags like the Restrap, but not if they rub my legs.
    Do you have any recommendations?
    Thank you

    1. Josh Lipton says:

      Generally, speaking all of these style of saddle bags are sufficiently narrow enough. We did have one customer come in who this was an issue for and they went through and tested out all of the bags, discovering that the Apidura Saddle Pack was the narrowest where it counted for them.

  3. carl mill says:

    that would be awesome,

Leave a comment.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *


20% off ALL Ortlieb Bag Closeouts! Shop Closeouts

Scroll to Top